Indian coal power: a pathway to reduced emissions16 April 2021
A new report from the IEA Clean Coal Centre* recognises a continuing role for coal as an affordable, secure and dispatchable power source for India’s growing economy (although with a gradually diminishing share of the overall energy mix as renewables expand). The IEACCC report, summarised here, describes a potential pathway to reduced emissions from the Indian coal fleet, which must address the high ash content of indigenous fuel sources. It presents a scenario for Indian coal power to 2040 that envisages a transition to high-efficiency, low-emissions technologies, and deployment, from around 2030 onwards, of CCUS
India is a vast country of 1.37 billion people that has undergone rapid economic growth over the last 20 years to become the world’s fifth largest economy. Total power generation has increased by 40% over the last decade, there is abundant generating capacity and most people now have access to electricity. Coal-fired power has remained dominant with a 72% (1135 TWh) share of total generation in 2019 due to the country’s enormous coal reserves and limited oil and gas. Energy demand will continue to grow and although the government of India has ambitious plans to meet much of the expected growth with up to 400 GW of wind and solar power capacity by 2030, coal will continue to play a fundamental role in providing India with dispatchable power and energy security for the next 20 years and beyond.
However, the Indian coal fleet emitted 1.1 GtCO2 in 2019 and contributes to poor air quality, due to emissions of SO2, NOx and particulate matter, with associated impacts on health, ecology and economy. A new report from the IEA Clean Coal Centre has identified a pathway whereby India can continue to grow its economy relying on its own coal resources, while reducing emissions of CO2 and improving local air quality. A key challenge is the impact of burning high ash content (25–50%), indigenous coal on plant performance and emissions management.
Reducing carbon emissions with a flexible, efficient fleet
In India the average coal unit efficiency is around 35% compared to state-of-the-art efficiency of some 47.5% (LHV). Thus CO2 emissions from India’s coal fleet could be reduced significantly through a combination of retiring or upgrading older units and building new efficient ones (Figure 1).
There are various incentive schemes to promote upgrading of subcritical plants and the upgrading of some small units (<200 MWe) has resulted in savings of over 100 kt/y coal and 165–190 kt/y of CO2 emissions at each unit with a return on investment in less than two years.
India’s coal-fired power plant installed capacity has more than quadrupled to over 205 GW (utility) in 20 years, with a further 33 GW under construction. The first supercritical (SC) unit came online in 2010 and now there is 52 GW of SC capacity. See Figure 2.
The first ultrasupercritical (USC) plant (NTPC’s Khargone) was commissioned in 2019. By 2023 India is expected to have 250 GW of utility coal- fired generating capacity in operation, almost a third of which will be SC or USC. The hope is that this impressive performance of improving efficiency will be continued.
Further reductions in emissions could be achieved through changes to dispatch mechanisms and implementation of supporting policies such as:
- continuing the transition towards economics- based merit-order dispatch to provide market incentives for more efficient, flexible units;
- introducing efficiency standards so all new units are supercritical as a minimum and ultrasupercritical from 2025;
- easing the regulatory process for retirement of inefficient units and replacement with new ones;
- encouraging greater use of digital tools to facilitate optimal operation, efficiency and flexibility; and
- supporting technical capacity building and international knowledge sharing in the manufacture and operation of high-efficiency, flexibleunits.
The ability to operate in a flexible manner will be key if coal power plants are to remain competitive in a market with a greater proportion of renewables. More emphasis will need to be placed on planning and readiness for likely changes in the market and operational environment.
Emissions controls and air quality
The introduction of more stringent emission standards for coal power in 2015 was a significant step in mitigating air pollutants, including SO2, NOx, and particulates. However, progress in meeting these standards has been slow with the deadline extended to 2022 and some NOx limits relaxed.
There is most debate about the ability to meet NOx emission standards. But the IEACCC has found that substantial NOx reductions are readily achievable in most Indian coal plants.
For example, significant NOx reduction (around 10%) and efficiency gains (up to 2 percentage points) can be achieved through optimisation and accurate monitoring of combustion parameters.
In combination with optimised combustion, primary NOx controls such as separated overfire air and low NOx burners can be used effectively to comply with emission limits of 300 mg/m3.
More costly secondary measures will be needed to achieve the stricter NOx limits for newer plants, but these technologies can be successfully applied even to the relatively high-ash environments associated with firing Indian coals.
Rather than seeking to delay implementation of the existing norms, the sector should work to anticipate the globally observed trend of progressively tightening standards.
CCUS, the ultimate goal
As the only means of imposing deep cuts on fossil fuel CO2 emissions, CCUS should represent the ultimate goal for India’s coal fleet. Although India actively supports research in CCUS, political backing for large-scale deployment has not
been strong. However, recent rapid growth in coal power capacity and more ambitious climate targets present a more favourable environment for CCUS.
Recent studies estimate that the country has the potential to store at least 100 GtCO2 (90 years of current coal emissions), even without considering emerging opportunities in basalt and deep coal seams. However, the true potential will only be clear once more targeted characterisation has been carried out. The IEACCC has mapped India’s coal plants against geological resources as a means of highlighting the most suitable storage locations and plant clusters for near-term development. See Figure 3.
The cost of retrofitting state-of-the-art CO2 capture systems to existing coal plants has fallen significantly following early demonstration, and will continue to do so if further planned developments take place in the USA and China. Progressively deploying CCUS on 26 GW of India’s high-efficiency capacity from 2030 to 2040 could avoid a further 750 Mt of CO2 emissions over the decade. As a means of developing the appropriate revenue streams and policy support required to progress CCUS in India, there is opportunity in linking the technology to the strong political drive behind India’s ‘Methanol Economy’ initiative to expand coal gasification.
India could take various steps to drive early demonstration of CCUS including:
- a more detailed assessment of geological storage potential including characterisation of promising saline aquifers in coal-producing regions;
- priority dispatch for CCUS-equipped coal plants, together with tariff pass-through of additional coal costs, could act as an incentive for early projects;
- enhanced oil recovery and CO2 conversion technologies can also play a role in kickstarting first mover projects, supported by incentives for domestic, low-carbon products;
- new coal plants in India should be ‘capture- ready’, including a storage assessment;
- government should co-ordinate an integrated, cross-sectoral technology demonstration strategy among relevant public sector undertakings; and
- CCUS should be explicitly included in India’s international climate commitments.
Initial financing of CCUS deployment will likely require international investment, international support, including through multi-lateral development banks, and policy incentives. Other incentives such as tax credits may be needed to further support CCUS deployment and wide- spread power system decarbonisation.
Coal power to 2040
Coal’s share of the Indian electricity market is likely to diminish but remain significant.
Figure 4 shows an IEACCC scenario for coal power to 2040, based on the NITI Aayog draft energy policy, 2017.
The replacement of 25 year old subcritical units with a range of HELE (high-efficiency, low-emissions) coal technologies decouples CO2 emissions (blue dashed line) from coal-fired generation (red line).
The addition of CCS from 2030 onwards to around 10% of the fleet reduces emissions further (green dashed line).
The results indicate that HELE plants with the addition of CCS on 26 GW of coal-fired capacity could avoid up to 4300 MtCO2 between 2021 and 2040, equivalent to roughly 215 MtCO2/y.
This IEACCC study offers a pathway to reduced emissions and improved air quality, while still using affordable and reliable coal power in a growing economy. Plant efficiency can be improved with some inexpensive measures. Emissions standards can be met in many instances without costly measures and payback of only a few years. The resulting improvements will have health, environmental and economic benefits. Market reforms to incentivise adoption of new, proven technologies will be required to achieve the desired improvements. Deploying HELE coal generation technology can help support government objectives, from improving air quality to operational flexibility in a market with increasing renewables penetration. Specific recommendations include:
- increased emphasis on ultrasupercritical
- technology or better by 2040, with remaining subcritical units confined to minimal operating hours;
- further focus on compliance with 2015 emissions standards using available technologies;
- CCUS – the groundwork such as storage assessment and regulatory development must be laid now if it is to remain an option;
- enabling power market to value all aspects of energy provision, including availability, flexibility, and grid reliability and resilience;
- further encouragement of international support in the form of both investment and expertise; and
- nurturing of India’s capacity to be a global centre of engineering excellence in HELE and CCUS technologies.
There is a real risk that prevailing perceptions of coal as an outmoded energy source, combined with financial challenges, will stifle efforts to transition to cleaner forms of coal power and slow the promising progress made in transforming India’s coal fleet.
Recognising that coal power will remain fundamental to the country’s pursuit of UN Sustainable Development Goals the use of HELE coal technologies and CCUS must be seen as key to India’s actions on both public health (SDG3) and climate change (SDG13).
* D Adams, T Lockwood, P Baruya, M Wiatros-Motyka, Q Zhu (2021), A pathway to reducing emissions from coal power in India,
IEA Clean Coal Centre, London, UK, 156 pp (https://www.iea-coal.org/report/a-pathway-to-reducing-emissions-from-coal-power-in-india-ieaccc-ciab/)