Life cycle analysis of pumped storage5 October 2023
A life cycle analysis of new-build closed-loop pumped storage hydro systems in the United States shows that, when the full impacts of materials and construction are taken into account, they have the lowest greenhouse gas emissions (CO2 equivalent per kWh) among energy storage technologies. The study was carried out by the US Department of Energy’s National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)* and funded by DOE’s Water Power Technologies Office.
Above: Closed-loop pumped storage hydro (graphic by Al Hicks, NREL)
The findings, says NREL, provide previously unknown insight into how closed-loop pumped storage hydropower – which is not connected to an outside body of water – compares to other grid-scale storage technologies.
The study compares pumped storage to four other technologies: compressed air (CAES); utility- scale lithium-ion batteries (LIBs); utility-scale lead-acid (PbAc) batteries; and vanadium redox flow batteries (VRFBs). Pumped-storage hydro and CAES are designed for long-duration storage, while batteries are intended to be used for a shorter time frame.
“Not all energy storage technologies provide the same services,” said Daniel Inman, one of the study’s authors. “We looked at compressed-air energy storage, which provides grid-scale energy storage and provides services like grid inertia and resilience. But pumped storage hydropower is about a quarter of the greenhouse gas emissions compared to compressed air.”
In examining pumped storage hydro, the researchers modelled their findings based on 39 preliminary designs from 35 proposed sites in the contiguous USA. The average closed-loop pumped storage hydro facility was assumed to have a power rating of 835 MW and a capacity of 2060 GWh of stored energy delivered annually. The base scenario also assumed the electricity would entirely come from renewables.
The researchers calculated the GWP (global warming potential) attributed to 1 kWh of stored electricity delivered to the nearest grid substation connection point. They estimated the GWP for pumped storage hydropower ranges from the equivalent of 58 to 502 gCO2/kWh. Hydropower achieved the lowest GWP, followed by LIBs, VRFBs, CAES, and PbAc batteries.
* “Life cycle assessment of closed-loop pumped storage hydropower in the United States,” by Daniel Inman, Gregory Avery, Rebecca Hanes, Dylan Hettinger, and Garvin Heath, all with NREL’s Strategic Energy Analysis Center.